9517 River Otter Drive
Reflection Isles, Fort Myers · $665,000
Screened pool and spa looking west across the lake toward the preserve

Multi-generational living at its finest.

9517 River Otter Drive · Reflection Isles · Fort Myers, FL 33912
$665,000
5 bedrooms 3 full baths, 1 half 3,441 sq ft Built 2015 Lake & preserve view Salt water pool & spa Flood Zone X

The lanai faces west over the lake, and the far bank is the Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve. Nobody is building over there. Evenings on this deck end with open water and sky, which is the part of the house photographs only half explain.

Inside, the plan quietly does something unusual. Alongside four bedrooms and a bonus room, there is an attached one-bedroom suite with its own outside door, its own living room, a kitchenette and its own washer and dryer. Family who stay a while, a parent moving closer, or a business that needs its own entrance all fit here without anybody losing their privacy.

Before you drive out

Walk all 3,441 square feet, right now

Living room open to the kitchen, the view you walk into in the 3D tour Open the 3D tour Every room, floor to ceiling. Then come stand on the lanai, because that part does not photograph.
Why people stop on this one

Four things worth the drive

The lake with the Six Mile Cypress Slough Preserve on the far bank

A view that cannot be built on

Water behind the house and preserve on the other side. No rooftops across the lake, and no prospect of any.

The attached suite's kitchenette with full size refrigerator

A suite with its own front door

One bedroom, a living room, a kitchenette, its own laundry, and a separate outside entrance. Built wheelchair accessible.

Salt water pool and sun loungers under the screen enclosure

Salt water pool, heated spa

Screened, paver deck, west-facing. New salt system and automatic fill went in during 2026.

Reflection Isles clubhouse and resort style pool from the air

$410 a month covers more than you expect

Fibre internet and cable, lawn care, irrigation water, sewer, trash, security, and the clubhouse, resort pool, gym and courts.

The house

Twenty-two photographs

The practical side

The things you were going to ask anyway

Build
2015, concrete block
Tile roof, stucco and stone, three-car garage.
Flood zone
Zone X
The zone lenders do not require flood insurance in. From FEMA, not the MLS field.
Storm protection
Built-in casings upstairs
Upstairs windows close from inside, so no ladder before a storm.
HOA
$410 monthly
Cable, internet, lawn, irrigation, sewer, trash, security, street maintenance.
Recently done
Paint, lighting, one A/C
Interior repainted throughout, new fixtures, and one of the two systems replaced June 2026.
Schools
Treeline Elementary
Middle and high are school choice. Daniels Parkway puts RSW, I-75 and both ball parks close.

Everything else we hold on the house ›

Come see it

The lanai is the reason people buy this house

Call or text and we will find a time that suits, most days including evenings. Already working with an agent? Have them reach out and we will take care of the rest.

Want the detail before you come? Running costs, what the inspections found, and every document down to the seller's disclosure and the association file. Read the full file. Nothing in it is held back for a phone call.